This last week I’ve been green with envy hearing all the feedback from everyone at GayRomLit (next year I will be there!), so have attempted to distract myself by tidying and sorting my workroom–okay, my side of the bedroom, but humour me here. In the process I discovered a bag of all my old swatches and abandoned projects I’d been saving. I couldn’t throw them away–the hoarder inside me wouldn’t let me. Instead, I decided to turn my weakness into an opportunity, and set about turning those scraps of knit and crochet into new items.
But first, why even bother with swatches? So many people don’t, and their stuff turns out all right, doesn’t it? Well, maybe…
Swatchers and Pantsers
The knitting world seems to be divided into two camps: the obsessive swatchers, and those who still wouldn’t make one if you sat them down at gunpoint. Those swatch -voiders are the pantsers, who just want to get going no matter the risk of knitting a garment only a giant could wear. I used to be a pantser, I’ll admit, and I reckon many knitters start out that way. However, there comes a point where if you want to make clothes that fit, you’re probably going to need to swatch. I can think of at least three projects I’ve made (and one rather recently, I’m ashamed to say), where I didn’t swatch and lived to regret it.
The zen of swatching
It’s all about getting into the right mindset. After all, I love knitting and crocheting, so making a swatch is doing something I love, right? I have to tell myself that I’m not wasting my time or my yarn. I’m spending it doing my hobby which should make me happy. I don’t think I’m ever going to be one of those bizarre knitters who enjoys swatching purely for the sake of playing with different yarns, like this knitter does, but I totally respect her dedication to the craft. Strangely enough though, I can happily doodle away making circular crochet motifs that I have no particular use for, yet tell me to knit a square and I rebel. Maybe it’s the whole back and forth thing. I’m much happier working out from the middle.
But there are other reasons for swatching instead of ensuring you match the gauge, as Julie Theaker outlines in her fabulous article here. What about the drape of the fabric? Will your cast on method work? How will the yarn behave in the washing machine? If you look on swatching as an essential learning journey, it becomes more fun, or so the theory goes. I’m getting there, slowly.
When you can get away without swatching
Scarves. What is a scarf, anyway, but a really long swatch? The same goes for dishcloths (although Chris is the only person I know who admits to knitting her own dishcloths!), and smaller, fit-as-you-go-projects. Most hats worked from the top down should be fine too, as you can simply stop increasing when you’ve reached the right size. Triangular shawls which work out from the centre are usually safe too, but just make sure you have enough yarn! This was my most recent disaster: a shawl I didn’t swatch and didn’t even bother measuring as I was crocheting it up. If I had, I’d have seen I needed to get down the yarn shop, pronto. However, as I wanted to wear the shawl at Eroticon which was only a week away, I really didn’t have time to make it larger. Annoyingly enough, swapping up a hook size at the beginning would have solved everything, and not left me with a shawl so small I have to pin it to get it stay together.
My philosophy now is that I won’t bother swatching if I don’t mind frogging the beginning of something if I get it wrong. Everything else gets swatched, though.
Swatch makes–beyond the sampler blanket
Not that there’s anyth
ing wrong with a sampler blanket, but I was keen to find some other ideas for my collection of swatches and scraps. I combed the web and found some wonderfully creative makes from other knitters, such as bangles, scarves, bags, phone cosies, Christmas decorations, and even plant pots!
Of course, the very simplest swatch makes involve doing very little at all other than weaving the ends away. If the yarn and stitch are suitable, you then could have yourself a coaster, a washcloth, a lens cleaning cloth or a doll’s blanket. A row of blanket stitch or a crocheted edging will take it up a level, but still be simplicity itself (unless you can’t crochet, in which case you need to learn now!)
So, here are a few pics of my swatches, and what I’ve done (or plan to do) with them.
These leftover granny squares looked perfect for making a mug cosy. I like my tea piping hot, so I really would use one of these. The cosy itself was simple to make, and the instructions are all over on Ravelry.


The following pieces all fall into the colour spectrum for my ongoing piece of freeform crochet (as inspired by Renate Kirkpatrick’s Freeform Crochet and Beyond), so I’m going to try to work them into it in some way. I might turn the largest of the pink broomstick crochet swatches (centre picture) into a phone cosy for my mum, though.
You can see what I’ve made so far in the picture below. I’ve now decided I’m making a bag (probably for my daughter, as I don’t like pink), and have cut myself a template so I don’t make it too big by accident. Freeform crochet is great fun as it feels like doodling again, and you can experiment to your heart’s content.It’s also a great way of using up small scraps of leftover yarn:
The following pics aren’t even my swatches. These were in the knitting bag I inherited from my gran. I haven’t been able to part with them for sentimental reasons, but they definitely aren’t doing anyone any good sitting in storage. I think the larger, stripe textured swatch could be made into a small purse–perhaps a make-up bag if lined.
As for the garter stitch squares? I couldn’t stand the aqua colour so I gave those to my daughter to use as doll blankets. The cream one is going to be used as a base for some yarn embroidery (inspired by the examples below), and then possibly used as a coaster or turned into a bag for my daughter.
And finally, this is my very first piece of knitting (unless you count the doll scarf I made as a child). I want to use it in some way, but I’m stuck for ideas. It isn’t a colour I’d want to wear or use in accessories, so what could I do with it? Any suggestions, peeps?
Of course, when inspiration fails, you could always use your swatches to indulge in a bit of lighthearted yarn bombing, and brighten up your locality:
So what about the rest of you: swatchers or pantsers? And has anyone else got into a pickle when they didn’t swatch, or do you have any nifty repurposed swatch projects you want to share?
Josephine Myles first learnt to crochet when she was eighteen. After making one beret that turned into a teacosy and frustrated at the crappy choice of yarn in her local shops, she decided the craft just wasn’t for her. Fast forward ten years, and having a bun in the oven prompted Jo to pick up her hook again to crochet some teeny-tiny baby things. Fortunately, by this time the world had caught up with her and there were all kinds of sexy yarns out there to indulge in. A few years later she taught herself knitting and dressmaking, and she hasn’t looked back since.
When she’s not busy with yarn or sewing machine, Jo can be found with her head in a book, pottering in the garden or running around after her daughter. She should probably get back to writing the steamy manlove novels, shouldn’t she?
Jo’s website and blog: http://josephinemyles.com/
Twitter: http://twitter.com/JosephineMyles
Facebook author page: http://www.facebook.com/josephine.myles.authorpage
Ravelry profile: http://www.ravelry.com/people/Anna-Jo














Tam
I obviously come from a family of pantsers (also my writing style, perhaps its a genetic trait) because I’ve never even heard of yarn swatches. I thought you were just supposed to wing it? LOL Those Christmas balls are cute. Fun for kind of an artsy crafty type tree. You could do a long squiggly chain like that variegated purple one and make it garland.
Josephine Myles
Honestly, Tam–how do you ever expect ot knit something to the right size if you wing it? ;P
Yeah, my writing started with pantsing, but I’m getting a bit more structured with that too.
I’m definitely making a few more Christmas decs this year. I have some gorgeous crocheted snowflakes already. Love the idea of a squiggly garland! They always decorate with handknitted stuff at the American Museum in Bath. I love going round there every December to see the displays
Prue
I’m inclined to be a pantser but have had enough whoopsies that I now knit tension squares – and hate it!!! It isn’t knitting to my way of thinking

My mum knitted beautifully and started her knitting career on dishcloths! My sister never had to do that – she knits beautifully too. Puts my efforts to shame and I’m no slouch.
I love the blue and gold! I need to be more adventurous. At present indulging in making up my own pattern but can only do it when fully awake.
I can’t wear anything with wool, cashmere, alpaca etc so getting nice woolies is a real problem.
I love the mug warmer!
Now, where are those knitting needles…?
Josephine Myles
What is it with the dishcloths?! Maybe I should give it a go someday. Perhaps they’re loads better than the ones you can buy in the shops. Might make cleaning a bit more cheerful, too
The blue and gold in the first picture? That’s a crochet stitch called bee stitch. I had fun experimenting with those squares. They were more me trying out a new stitch than actual swatches for garments, which meant I enjoyed making them.
Making up your own patterns is definitely fun to do, but yeah, you need to concentrate, don’t you? So far I’ve only done it with really simple knits.
Prue
From what my mum said, there isn’t anything great about knitting dishcloths
My mistake – the blue and gold was on one of the links you gave.
I’d really like to crochet – my gran used to make bedspreads out of cotton! They were so lacy and delicate. Don’t suppose anyone does that sort of thing these days.
Josephine Myles
Oh yes, that blue and gold project caught my eye too. Those colours were perfect together.
I can’t imagine crocheting a delicate, lacy bedspread. Doing a set of small snowflakes to decorate the Christmas tree was enough of a fiddle. I do like to do the occasional fine crochet project, though, like bookmarks. Those are fun.
Liam Grey
Well, I usually do knit swatches for sweaters, but the last one ended up being off, and we didn’t bother checking the gauge on the actual sweater (because I’m normally spot on) and I ended up having to rip the whole thing out. The swatch lied! Or I changed my tension working on the sweater. Naaah, I blame the swatch.
Josephine Myles
ARRGH!!! That must be horribly, horribly frustrating. I reckon swatches can lie if you knit them grudgingly. It’s bound to affect your tension. I’m a horribly tight knitter and crocheter anyway, so I don’t tend to have this problem, but I do nearly always need to go up one or two needle sizes from the pattern.
Kate McMurray
Ha, someone could write a whole essay on plotting vs. pantsing in creative pursuits. I’m definitely a plotter as a writer, and so it is with knitting. That is, I usually swatch, unless I’m knitting something like a scarf where the sizing doesn’t matter that much. (But for a sweater? So much swatching.) Most of my swatches just wind up back in the giant plastic bin where I keep my yarn stash, but now I may steal some of these ideas. I like those Christmas ornaments; I’ve got some styrofoam balls from some other project that might help with those.
(And, Cole, it was great meeting you in Albuquerque!)
Josephine Myles
Hi Kate–don’t you dare rub it in about GRL!
It does seem to be the case that those who plan in one type of creative pursuit do so in others. Definitely a fascinating thing to investigate further. I tend to be a bit of both most of the time. I will plan a bit, but I know if I overplan I won’t ever get started. There’s generally an element of winging it, and I love to improvise as I’m going along. Not in my current cardigan project, though. I’m going by the book on this one!
Cole
I loved meeting you too sweetie! I loved hearing you talk about Brooklyn…ahh brings back memories
The first time I got drunk was in Park Slope!
Cole
I’m a pantser, but mostly because I don’t knit large form fitting projects, mostly scarves, hats, gloves, and socks. I do swatches mostly to try out new patterns and see how I like them, or to see how a fiber feels knitted up against my skin (because the texture is always different knitted than when it is on the skein!). Yarn in so expensive that I have a really hard time knitting swatches, but then when I do I usually just take pictures and notes and then frog them.
I love the line about yarn bombing — reminds me of Sarah Black’s book, The Apache Kid. Sarah Black rocks!
Josephine Myles
Oh yeah, sounds like you can get away with it if you knit those kinds of things. I don’t swatch for socks–I just frog them and start again if I get it wrong.
It’s definitely harder to bring yourself to swatch if you use expensive yarn. I do like to put swatches through the washing machine, though, so I can’t really reuse the yarn for the project after that.
I haven’t read that book–will have to check it out!
Josephine Myles
Oh yeah, and I hope you had a fabulous time at GRL! I so wish I could have been there.
Cel
I’m sort of half way on the swatching. If I have used the yarn or a very similar one before then no swatch. But new yarns and new needles can make biiiiig surprises. A lot of the time I treat the beginning of the project as a swatch – work a couple of inches and if it isn’t right, I rip and try again.
Josephine Myles
Good point–you don’t really have to bother if you know your tension with that yarn and size of needle, although different stitch patterns can sometimes make a difference.
I think many knitters tell themselves they’ll rip it back if it isn’t right, but then can’t bear to do it and carry on knitting. It’s great if you can be that disciplined!
Rhys Ford
We TOTALLY missed you at GRL. You’re one of the authors I’d like to buy a drink for and say thank you for writing.
Josephine Myles
Aww, thanks Rhys! I’ll definitely be there next year. I just couldn’t afford it this year, but am well on my way to saving up for 2013. It sounds like it was a blast, and there’s so many people I’d love to meet in person who were there
Did you have a fabulous time?
Rhys Ford
Fantastic time! Seriously, very lovely. People were quite warm and welcoming. Totally understand the financial aspect of it. Couldn’t do the first GRL but oh, this one was perfect. Saving up for Atlanta too. Really hope to see you there!
Josephine Myles
It’s a date!